Head to head
NICETOWN vs Amazon Basics Blackout Curtains: Which Wins?
The default pick against the budget pick: comparing NICETOWN and Amazon Basics blackout curtains.
#1 in our rankings · Best overall
NICETOWN Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2
Best for: Anyone needing reliable blackout in a specific size or color.
#3 in our rankings · Best value
Amazon Basics Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2
Best for: Standard windows where budget matters more than color choice.
Our recommendation
Buy Amazon Basics if it fits; buy NICETOWN if it does not. The fabrics block light the same way: triple weave, no coating. The entire price difference buys selection: NICETOWN's dozens of colors and full size ladder against Amazon Basics' handful of options. Measure your window, check the Basics size chart, and if a standard size in a neutral color works, keep the difference. If not, NICETOWN is worth every cent of the premium.
Size and color range
NICETOWN covers 63 to 108-inch lengths and dozens of colors. Amazon Basics covers the common sizes in neutrals. Odd windows and designed rooms need NICETOWN; standard windows do not care.
Fabric and blocking
Both use triple-weave construction with no sprayed coating. In dark colors at equal coverage, light-blocking performance is effectively identical. Neither has a meaningful fabric advantage.
Price
Amazon Basics is the lowest-priced triple-weave option in this group. The savings are real but modest in absolute terms: curtains are not where the big money goes in a room.
Choose NICETOWN Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2 if…
- You need a specific length, width, or color
- The window is non-standard sized
- The curtains are a visible design element
Choose Amazon Basics Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2 if…
- Your window takes a standard size
- A neutral color works in the room
- You want the lowest price for real blackout fabric
Spec-by-spec comparison
| Spec | NICETOWN Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2 | Amazon Basics Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Price tier | Mid-range | Budget |
| Construction | Triple-weave blackout fabric | Triple-weave polyester blackout |
| Set | 2 panels | 2 panels |
| Header | Grommet, fits rods up to 1.6" | Grommet top |
| Sizes | Widths from 42", lengths 63" to 108" | — |
| Care | — | Machine washable |
| Best for | Anyone needing reliable blackout in a specific size or color. | Standard windows where budget matters more than color choice. |
| Skip if | A standard window in a neutral color where the budget pick suffices. | You need an unusual size, length, or specific decor color. |
Strengths and limitations
NICETOWN Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2
Strengths
- True triple-weave fabric, no coating to peel
- Sold as two-panel sets with 1.6-inch grommets
- Widest size range: 63 to 108-inch lengths
- Dozens of colors
Limitations
- No dedicated thermal or noise-dampening engineering
- Grommet-only header on the core line
- Mid-range pricing over budget triple-weave options
Amazon Basics Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2
Strengths
- Triple-weave fabric at the lowest price here
- No coating to crack or peel
- Grommet top slides easily
- Machine washable
Limitations
- Limited colors and sizes
- Grommet-only header
- No thermal or noise engineering story
How they fit the wider field
- NICETOWN Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2: ranked #1 (Best overall) in The Best Blackout Curtains. Read the full NICETOWN Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2 review.
- Amazon Basics Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2: ranked #3 (Best value) in The Best Blackout Curtains. Read the full Amazon Basics Blackout Curtain Panels, Set of 2 review.
Neither one quite right? The full rankings cover 10 picks matched to different buyers.
Made your call?
Questions, answered
Is the blackout quality actually the same?
Through the fabric, yes: both are triple weave. Real-world darkness depends more on sizing and mounting than on brand, so buy the one that lets you cover the window generously.
Which lasts longer?
Both should last similarly: triple-weave fabric does not peel or crack like coated curtains. Wash gentle and cold, and either lasts years.